Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting The Old Mill. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
Old Mill Gumbo
I have had several bowls of gumbo at multiple restaurants but the Old Mill gumbo is by far the absolute best I have had since our trip to New Orleans!!!! I actually thought I was back there!!!! It's absolutely amazing, authentic and done proper! HANDS DOWN!!!!
Crab Claw Dinner
It's absolutely delicious! The best crab claws in town.
Crab Claws
These were great fried golden brown no need for any sauce.
Jumbo Gulf Shrimp
I have look high and low here in the Wiregrass for real fresh gulf shrimp and have had poor luck until now. The Old Mill is awesome! Great service. Great food and great friendly atmosphere.. Can't wait to go back again! Very family friendly too! We love The Old Mill Restaurant in Dothan Al. The Dixons!
Filet Mignon
absolutely amazing, seasoned perfectly, cooked exactly how i wanted, and super juicy.
Ribeye
This is my favorite place in the entire Wiregrass area!! The steaks melt in your mouth and the service is always on point!!!
Steak & Shrimp
Everyone at the table ordered steak and shrimp the steaks were cooked perfectly and the shrimp were the best we have had in a long time. Quality Quality Quality
Fried pickles
Pretty good, I'm a big fan of fried pickles and it's super hard to find them in spears. I don't like the chip method, always ends up to salty and overly breaded.
Chicken Alfredo
I got the Blackened Chicken Alfredo. It was delicious as always, it actually seemed to have more sauce than normal which made it even better I hope that is like that from now on. My son had the same thing just not blackened and loved it. We are very frequent Old Mill customers.
Potato Skins
exactly what you'd expect, potato skins tasted like they were salted, perfect amount of bacon and cheese